Here’s why Daenerys’ dark decision made perfect sense despite the obvious questions

Here's why Daenerys' dark decision made perfect sense despite the obvious questions

Take heed to JOE’s model new GOT response present, The North Awaits, with Michael Fry & Carl Kinsella proper right here. 

Hearth and blood has all the time been coming.

At current, fairly a couple of mother and father in Eire are experiencing extra doubt, remorse and worry than Jon Snow.

Why? Nicely, since Recreation of Thrones first aired in 2011, 9 infants that have been born in Eire have been given the identify Khaleesi.

Sure, that is proper.

These youngsters now have a reputation that is impressed by a fictional struggle felony. Issues might be worse although, the youngsters could possibly be referred to as Joffrey!

The newest episode in Recreation of Thrones has seen the panorama in Westeros dramatically change after Daenerys rained hearth on the capital and at this second, we will not assist however dwell on Ramsay Bolton’s most well-known line: “If you assume this has a cheerful ending, you have not been paying consideration”.

The Mad Queen is right here and whereas that narrative choice has justifiably left loads of individuals perplexed, this is why it makes good sense regardless of the apparent points.

On this observe, we will look at Daenerys’ dramatic determination from three points 1) What Daenerys has truly stated all through the present, 2) what she has achieved, three) the writing for Daenerys in Season eight.

1) The North remembers.

This is a pattern of strains that Daenerys has stated through the years.

In fact, something may be taken out of context and 99% of characters in Recreation of Thrones have some blood on their palms, however they’re fairly telling.

On this level, it is value noting that not each single Recreation of Thrones fan has an encyclopaedic information of the present, nevertheless, The Mad Queen indicators have been all the time there. These strains might have been directed in the direction of ‘evil’ or ‘dangerous’ characters, however they’re essential in displaying Dany’s angle to dying and passing the deadly sentence.

“When my dragons are grown… we’ll lay waste to armies and burn cities to the bottom” – Season 2, episode four

“I’ll take what’s mine with hearth and blood” – Season 2, episode 6.

They’re apparent indicators.

In Season four,  Jorah implores her to point out mercy to the masters of Yunkai. “I wouldn’t be right here that will help you if Ned Stark had accomplished to me what you need to do to the masters of Yunkai,” he stated.

In the identical episode, Dany replies to Jorah by saying: “They will stay in my new world or they will die of their previous one.”

In Season 6, Dario Naharis places it bluntly, “You weren’t made to take a seat on a chair in a palace. You’re a conquer, Daenerys Stormborn.” This hints at an important distinction that must be made. In Essos, Dany was seen as a liberator however in Westeros, she’s an invader.

After crossing The Slender Sea, she may need the most effective intentions of breaking the wheel and ending slavery, however the final Targaryen in Westeros was her father and we all know how his reign ended.

If you take a look at issues logically, the individuals of the Seven Kingdoms seen him as a tyrant that needed to “burn all of them” – why would his daughter be seen any totally different?

Examine this angle with the respect, admiration, and love that Jon Snow evokes.

This level is echoed in Season eight when she tells Jon that: “I noticed them gathered round you. I noticed the best way they checked out you. I do know that look. So many individuals have checked out me that method however by no means right here.”

In the newest episode, she says that: “Much more individuals in Westeros love you than love me. I don’t have love right here. I solely have worry.”

To compound issues, Daenerys additionally despatched her forces to battle alongside Jon within the struggle towards the military of the lifeless. She misplaced hundreds of Dothraki, Unsullied, and her dragon, Viserion.

What does she have to point out for it? A scarcity of respect, loyalty and belief. That is what.

Thrones spinoff

Elsewhere, after the Masters broke their promise and tried to retake Mereen, Daenerys’ plan is to “crucify the masters. I’ll set their fleets afire. I’ll kill each final considered one of their troopers and return their cities to the dust. That’s my plan.”

Tyrion talks her out of it.

When Dany lands in Dragonstone, she varieties a small council and has Olenna Tyrell as considered one of her advisors. The Queen of Thorns tells Dany that: “Commoners and nobles are all youngsters actually. They gained’t obey you until they worry you. You’re a dragon. Be a dragon.”

In Season 7, episode four, when Tyrion’s plan to take Casterly Rock fails, Daenerys says: “Sufficient with the intelligent plans. I’ve three giant dragons. I’m going to fly them to the Pink Maintain.”

In one of the current episodes, Tormund exclaims, “What sort of individual climbs on a fucking dragon? A madman, or a king!” On the phrase “madman” the digital camera cuts to Daenerys earlier than specializing in Jon for “king.”

A particularly intelligent little bit of foreshadowing.

2) “He was no dragon.”

Listed here are a few of the issues that Daenerys has carried out through the years that would painting her in a really totally different mild.

But once more, nearly all of these deaths concerned characters that we perceived as ‘evil’ or ‘dangerous’. On that notice, it is value noting that Seasons 7 and eight are massively totally different than what got here earlier than as a result of we’re viewing Dany’s selections via the prisms of the opposite ‘hero’ characters that we love.

Jorah, Missandei, and Barristan have been all dedicated to her, Tyrion, Varys, Sansa and Jon all have very totally different views, experiences, and loyalties. Nothing was ever executed to influence the viewer that she could possibly be incorrect.

Equally, 99% of characters in Recreation of Thrones have some blood on their palms, Dany is not any totally different to anybody else, however the next examples are fascinating when making an attempt to know her psyche previous to the destruction of King’s Touchdown…

Viserys’ dying

Within the aftermath of the newest episode, the showrunners overtly talked about the truth that Dany remained chilly, impassive, and unmoved to Viserys’ demise.

This was the primary purple flag however all of us ignored it as a result of her brother was a little bit of a bastard.

Mirri Maz Duur

When Khal Drogo acquired sick, Mirri Maz Duur saved his life however intentionally left him in a vegetative state. To be able to save Drogo’s life, the witch carried out a ritual that drew its energy from the dying of Daenerys’ son, inflicting her kid’s stillbirth and monstrous look.

Daenerys burned Mirri Maz Duur alive in a pyre.

The handmaiden in Qarth

After a plot to kill her troopers and abduct her dragons failed, Dany exacted her revenge by locking her handmaiden and Xaro in an empty vault to die.

The Mass crucifixion

On the street to Meereen in Season four, Daenerys discovered 163 slave youngsters that have been crucified. She determined to crucify 163 masters in retaliation with out regard for his or her particular person guilt or innocence.

Ser Barristan suggested her to be extra merciful however she ignored him.

On an analogous word, she as soon as stated the next to Ser Jorah: “You counselled me towards rashness as soon as in Qarth. I didn’t pay attention. All of it labored out properly.”

Revenge for Ser Barristan

After Ser Barristan is killed by The Sons of the Harpy in Season 5, Daenerys angrily rounds up every of the leaders of Meereen’s noble households within the catacombs the place Viserion and Rhaegal reside. She feeds two of them to her dragons to be able to intimidate the remaining.

Was the person responsible? Harmless? We don’t know and Dany didn’t appear to care.

In Mereen, Dany’s authority was solely solidified via violence and her management was a little bit of a multitude. She needed to be sort and simply, however violence was the one approach to succeed.

She crushed the riot from The Sons of the Harpy by means of violence. She killed the Masters with violence. Previous to this, she burned the leaders of Astapor alive and took their military. Her solely main army success in Westeros was when she unleashed the complete energy of Drogon towards the Lannister and Tyrell forces in the course of the Loot Practice Assault sequence.

Violence, hearth and blood has been profitable for her.

Why would anybody assume that her tactic to take the Iron Throne can be any totally different?

The prophecy

Everyone knows the well-known imaginative and prescient that she experiences whereas imprisoned within the Home of the Timeless

Dany sees herself strolling via the Purple Maintain’s throne room. The ceilings are destroyed and it is snowing – maybe it is ash after her current destruction of the capital?

Daenerys appeared destined to turn into the queen of the ashes – one thing that she was vehemently against in earlier seasons.

The Mass Burning

In Season 6, she’s captured by the Dothraki and brought hostage to Vaes Dothrak.

Dany proceeds to burn all of the khals alive and she or he has the remaining Dothraki promise that they’ll “kill my enemies of their iron fits and tear down their stone homes.”

The Tarlys

Daenerys executes Randal and Dickon Tarly after they refused to bend the knee and settle for her rule. Tyrion implored her to allow them to take the black, or ship them to jail.

Within the Season eight opener when Sam meets Daenerys, John Bradley described the Mom of Dragons as “psychopathic” and that his character lastly discovered “the lengths that she’ll go to if anyone decides to disobey her and the way her quest for energy appears to know no ethical code on the subject of that.”

We all know precisely what he means.

Season eight

In the newest episodes, Daenerys’ psychological state has deteriorated after a collection of deaths, betrayals, and selections.

Ser Jorah, Melisandre, and Rhaegal have all died. Varys and Tyrion have conspired towards her. She has discovered that Jon has the higher declare to the Iron Throne. To compound issues, the person she loves has now spurned her affections and she or he now understands that she’ll by no means be beloved by the individuals of Westeros.

In Dany’s thoughts, if cannot be liked as a ruler on the Iron Throne, she’ll select worry.

three) Did Dave and Dan do Dany soiled?

To start with, we’re extremely conscious that Recreation of Thrones is a fantasy present with dragons, magic, ice zombies, and resurrection.

Nevertheless, there is a purpose why it is the most important present on the earth and after seven seasons of viewers participation and emotional funding, followers need to have their voices heard and loads of Daenerys followers assume that the present’s creators, David Benioff and D.B Weiss, have botched Dany’s arc.

That is truthful nevertheless it’s value noting that each males are working from the broad directions of George R.R. Martin.

After shifting previous the unique supply materials, the present is presently in unexplored terrain and whereas there shall be variations between the upcoming books and the TV present, the details would be the similar.

On this observe, we will assume that Martin’s ebook will function the identical arc with Daenerys as The Mad Queen.

Martin select this route, not Benioff and Weiss.

Equally, one of many fundamental the reason why all of us love Recreation of Thrones is as a result of it is a present that always subverts expectations. Christ, Martin determined to kill off Ned Stark on the finish of the primary e-book and he topped this at The Purple Wedding ceremony.

Shocks, twists, and drama is the norm.

The choice to show Daenerys evil is not all that shocking when seen towards the dramatic historical past of the present.


Nevertheless, nearly all of viewers nonetheless cant shake the sensation that Dany’s transition simply feels a bit hole.

Breaker of chains, liberator of cities, a saviour to those who have been born into servitude, Daenerys Targaryen has persistently been portrayed as a robust, variety, however steel-hearted chief.

Once we first meet her, she’s handled like a bit of meat by her brother and bought off like an animal.

Eight seasons later and she or he’s the Dragon Queen, a pacesetter who conquered lands and amassed trustworthy followers, nevertheless, the current collection of losses and threats to her potential place as Queen of the Seven Kingdoms, has brought about her to snap and turn out to be The Mad Queen.

Merely put, the present hasn’t carried out sufficient in Season eight to justify this seismic shift however that is to not say that the indicators weren’t there already – as beforehand mentioned.

Okay, we all know that the losses of Jorah, Missandei, and Rhaegal have been an enormous think about her altering psychology. Added to this, there’s the truth that she has now discovered that her new lover has a greater declare to the Iron Throne – a pursuit that has outlined her life and been an important factor to her since start.

Daenerys Mad Queen

Emilia Clarke has beforehand stated that Daenerys’ determination cannot merely be outlined by ‘Targareyn insanity’ as a result of “it is simply grief. It’s harm and she or he has this capability to make this harm really feel slightly bit much less for a minute. And the sensation is to fucking kill her (Cersei). Whenever you really feel that a lot failure, disappointment, disgrace, harm, and misplaced love, there’s solely a lot ache that you would be able to deal with earlier than you snap.”

The factor is, it isn’t the duty of an actor to elucidate what’s occurring within the plot throughout an interview, that ought to be obvious through the episode itself.

Equally, not each fan goes to recollect Maester Aemon’s throwback line that “A Targaryen alone on the earth is a horrible factor” or a dialog that Dany had with Jorah/Ser Barristan in Meereen.

Previous to the destruction of King’s Touchdown, the TV present quickly turned Dany into a multitude of stereotypes in a bid to elucidate her horrific motivations.

Spurned lover after Jon turned down her advances. A paranoid chief that is involved about traitors in her council – she was confirmed to be proper. A ruler that is unfit to steer as a result of she hates having her authority challenged. A lady that is mourning the lack of her buddies, advisors and “youngsters.”

All this with out mentioning the Targaryen bloodline and their historical past of insanity.

The storyline was all the time destined to finish this manner. Sadly, Ramsay Bolton was proper.

How many individuals have been paying consideration, although?



if (consentManager.isAllowed(‘fb’))

fbq(‘init’, ‘453001074905905’);
fbq(‘monitor’, “PageView”);
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘ViewContent’);

consentManager.sentEventFbPixel = true;